Best Nespresso capsules, by community rating
146 capsules rated from published opinion, best first. Special Reserve Hawaii Kona leads at 2.8 out of 5.
Each score is the mean of opinions read in full from public sources, counted once per author. A capsule appears only once at least five independent authors have been read, so a capsule missing from this list is one we have not gathered enough evidence about — not one that scored badly. Every excerpt links to where it was published.
146 capsules ranked

Special Reserve Hawaii Kona
Special Reserve Hawaii Kona is a limited Original Line espresso with a gentle, sweet, cereal-to-chocolate character that can vary noticeably by production year. A good batch can be smooth, aromatic and distinctive, while another can taste mild, ashy, thin or less expressive; a little sugar or milk can work, but this…
Source (opens in a new tab)I just got my shipment of the Inizio, Hawaii Kona, and the Vivida b12 ones. I’ve been impressed with them.
Source (opens in a new tab)Hawaii Kona - I was most excited about this one. I like it, but I don’t love it. I still prefer Puerto Rico. If Hawaii wasn’t 28 USD, I would probably buy a few more boxes for some variety in my…

Whisky Essence
Whisky Essence divides opinion: some drinkers enjoy its whisky-like character and cacao notes, especially over ice or with cream, while others find the flavour too strong or unpleasant. It suits people who enjoy an intense flavoured coffee or a softer milk-based version.
Source (opens in a new tab)It pairs great with brown sugar. I do that with some half n half over ice.
Source (opens in a new tab)I’ve been drinking it over ice, as the box suggests possibly doing, and it’s been fabulous. I finished my first box today and I believe it to be the best of my past order.

Chocolate Fudge
Opinions on Chocolate Fudge are sharply divided. Some people find the chocolate note weak, waxy or almost fermented, while others enjoy it with ice, sweet creamer or cold foam.
Source (opens in a new tab)I bought 2 sleeves and can’t make myself drink them.
Source (opens in a new tab)Hi! I’ve had both the chocolate & the peppermint. In my opinion the peppermint is extremely good and the chocolate is just so so.

Filter Style Mild
Filter Style Mild is an extremely polarizing Original Line filter-style capsule. Some drinkers praise its fresh aroma, juicy character and resemblance to drip coffee, while others find it weak, watery, tea-like, mediocre or over-extracted. The cup can change noticeably with the brew setting, so it suits people who…
Source (opens in a new tab)but not that much. I use them as lungo so they're not that watered down anymore but I'm also not buying them again.
Source (opens in a new tab)I completely agree. I ordered it after reading your review and its in my top 3 flavors now

Hazelino Muffin
Hazelino Muffin is a strongly polarising flavoured coffee: some people enjoy its sweet hazelnut character, especially with milk, while many describe an artificial, burnt or unpleasant aftertaste. It is a poor fit for people who dislike flavoured coffee or burnt aftertaste.
Source (opens in a new tab)I'm experiencing the same with Hazelino specifically. I thought I was crazy, but I've made it multiple times with all different variables: iced, hot, sweet creamer, not as sweet creamer.... and it…
Source (opens in a new tab)It’s the only pod I can’t drink. It’s disgusting

Caramelizio
Caramelizio has a strongly negative and formulation-sensitive reception. The coffee is often described as bland, underwhelming or actively unpleasant, although oat milk with extra caramel can make it more appealing and the capsule works acceptably for some drinkers. The older and reformulated versions are described…
Source (opens in a new tab)I, as well as my friends and others' comments I have read, are extremely disappointed by the change to the Carmelizio pod.
Source (opens in a new tab)I did think the Intenso, Melozio, and Caramelizio capsules weren’t bad - but I’d still take one of the espresso capsules as a latte or cappuccino over them 9/10 times.
Excerpts are quoted from public sources and belong to their authors. Follow the source link for full context.